As a follow up, we now have all of the Paladin Covenant legendaries implemented, and testable. We won’t spend much time talking about
Jahreszeiten der Fülle or
Pflichtgebundener Hammer as they are primarily unchanged from our last post
linked here.
The real talking point is between the Kyrian and Venthyr legendaries, as these are the two most popular covenant choices for Holy Paladin they are the most noteworthy.
Kyrian
The Kyrian Legendary was worded somewhat ambiguously initially, and now that we can test it, we know how it works.
Göttliche Resonanz will cast one additional
Heiliger Schock on the INITIAL target of your
Göttlicher Glockenschlag, every 5 seconds. This will add up to a fair amount of Holy Power over an encounter. However, a large portion of the
Heiliger Schock healing may go to waste, as there is no guarantee that person will benefit from a
Heiliger Schock that frequently. Due to the
Lichtschimmer cap, this also ensures this person will have
Lichtschimmer on them pretty much exclusively for an extended period of time. Some encounters, this may be a benefit or this may be used on a tank frequently. Overall, this legendary is a solid legendary, though it is competing with some heavy hitters for Paladin already, as the power level of our legendaries is quite high.
Venthyr
The real talk however, is in Venthyr’s
Strahlende Glut now that we have a better idea how this works. Essentially, how it works is as soon as you leave your own
Ascheweihung, it instantly disappears, but a portion of its cooldown (based on remaining duration) is instantly returned. This means in some scenarios you could get a mechanic forcing you to run out (and waste
Ascheweihung), or maybe even just stand in the raid if your group “needs” said
Ascheweihung healing. This is kind of unique, as far as mechanics go and could lead to problems.
The real strength of this legendary is in its current tuning values. Essentially skilled players will be able to track (probably with a weakaura) its remaining duration, if you leave after exactly 20s into your
Ascheweihungs duration, you can get its cooldown to roughly 2mins, coincidentally the cooldown of
Zornige Vergeltung. Previously, you could not get an
Ascheweihung with every
Zornige Vergeltung, but this legendary gives you that option which is certainly powerful. If an encounter has a predictable damage pattern, you could run 2-3 paladins with this legendary, and they would be able to stagger
Ascheweihungs and Wings to have very powerful raid cooldowns for practically every damage event of an encounter. This is somewhat concerning, as the damage potential of Venthyr Holy Paladin is still quite high, despite the nerfs. For more information on the nerfs to Paladin in a recent PTR build you can read about
it here.
In conclusion, the
Göttliche Resonanz legendary effect is a middle of the pack legendary, which could see some play, but has tough competition. The Necrolord and Night Fae legendaries are comparable in power, but are less represented as covenants for Holy Paladins. The Venthyr legendary, is still early and is a really cool idea mechanically but is probably slightly overtuned and could lead to abuse by stacking paladins on specific encounters to take advantage of very powerful short duration
Ascheweihungs.
Now that the new Covenant Legendaries for Paladin can finally be tested on the PTR, we have a much better idea of exactly how they work and interact with other abilities.
Kyrian
Göttliche Resonanz has had a significant change since it was last discussed - rather than casting
Göttlicher Glockenschlag additional times, instead it casts regular
Richturteils. Compared to how it was previously assumed to work, this will result in less Holy Power in situations with multiple targets, but more initial damage from
Richturteils on single target. It also obviously now won't proc
Läutende Klarheit or
Kampfmeditation with the extra casts. For how
Göttliche Resonanz actually works in practice, it's usually a 30 second buff that casts
Richturteil every 5 seconds. For each
Göttlicher Glockenschlag, you get 6 extra
Richturteils with a 5 second gap between each. However, it also seems to have a bug where if the initial
Göttlicher Glockenschlag hits more than one enemy, you actually get a 35 second buff, which results in an extra
Richturteil cast.
The extra
Richturteils still proc all the normal effects you'd expect them to, like
Tugendhafter Befehl,
Eifer, and the
Richturteil debuff itself. Awkwardly for both
Tugendhafter Befehl and
Eifer, there are a couple of bugs and issues that appear when you end up casting a lot of
Richturteils within a small timeframe. For
Tugendhafter Befehl, its buff doesn't actually get refreshed if you cast a second
Richturteil with the buff still active, so despite casting 6 or 7
Richturteils you'll only end up with extra
Tugendhafter Befehl procs from about half of them, depending on server lag. With
Eifer, if you cast
Richturteil very frequently you end up capping at 9 stacks very quickly, and then waste stacks as they're refreshed above 6. Ideally these problems will be addressed before 9.1 goes live, especially the
Tugendhafter Befehl bug, as it's essentially random whether each
Richturteil will give you another buff or not.
As far as how strong it looks to be for damage, it's not unlikely based on the current version that it will become the best Legendary for Kyrian. The
Richturteil damage and Holy Power alone is probably enough to rival
Letztes Urteil, not to mention the increased
Urteil des Templers damage from extra
Richturteil debuffs and the fact that it doesn't lose value in AoE situations like
Letztes Urteil does. Whether it really will be better or by how much remains to be seen, but judging by its current design and tuning, expect this to be a strong Legendary in the coming patch.
Venthyr
Strahlende Glut is still a very weird Legendary to try to wrap your head around. It's been clarified to cancel
Ascheweihung once you leave it, but the cooldown reduction it provides does not scale as you might expect. Up to around half of the 45 second duration, 22 seconds or so in, it will still provide 110 seconds of cooldown reduction for
Ascheweihung, which is only 10 seconds less than if you left it immediately after casting it. However, after this point the cooldown reduction is reduced at a much faster rate. This ends up with a strange outcome where there's very little change in the amount of cooldown reduction you receive until half of
Ascheweihung's duration is finished, after which its cooldown reduction is scaled down at a much faster rate.
The result of this is that you can use
Ascheweihung for essentially the entire duration of
Zornige Vergeltung plus a couple of seconds, cancel it, and then have it back off cooldown shortly after your next
Zornige Vergeltung comes off cooldown. Although this sounds very strong, it only ends up being around 15 extra seconds of
Ascheweihung compared to a normal 4 minute cooldown use. While you can also just wait the full 45 seconds on your last cast of
Ascheweihung each fight, since you don't need the extra cooldown reduction if you can't cast it again, it might not end up as strong as
Das Wahnsinnige Paragon for Venthyr.
Night Fae
Jahreszeiten der Fülle has thankfully had a design overhaul. It now doubles the effects of each Season for its middle 10 seconds. Since each buff lasts 30 seconds, you end up with 10 seconds of the normal buff, then 10 seconds of the empowered version, then another 10 seconds of the normal buff.
As you might have noticed,
Segen des Sommers's average damage is actually quadrupled rather than doubled, since both the chance to proc and the amount of damage are doubled rather than just one of them.
It's fairly difficult to evaluate the new version of this Legendary.
Segen des Sommers is by far the most valuable Season, so increasing its value by that much means that it's at least worth some consideration. Since in raid combat you can cast
Segen des Sommers prepull and have your season reset back to
Segen des Sommers on pull, you end up with more uptime on
Segen des Sommers than any other season anyway. There could be a build similar to current Kyrian with
Todesurteil and
Letzte Abrechnung, where
Todesurteil is used within the middle 10 seconds of
Segen des Sommers in order to buff its damage by proccing off regular casts within its window, but could also proc off the final hit of
Todesurteil. Alternatively, it could just be used on another class with a strong 10 second burst window every 3 minutes, like a Balance Druid. Either way, this is likely to be a Legendary with some niche uses at the very least, and has potential to be much better.
Necrolord
Pflichtgebundener Hammer hasn't received any recent changes. It's still a pretty underwhelming effect and is unlikely to change Necrolord's position compared to other covenants.