To Ion:People were happier in Legion because of gold from the mission table. Simply up the rewards to 500g or so from the BFA table and people will like the expansion a lot more.Crafting absolutely sucks since you gave it three tiers and so many mats to craft single items. You need to go back to the Cata way of crafting to find a way to revive crafting.Of course. IMHO.
"The playerbase is too diverse" is such a freaking cop-out. There's such a thing as STATISTICS for crying out loud. Get all the complaints, compile those to see which ones have more backing, and fix THOSE. It's not freaking rocket science.
He's still living in a bubble "oh the negativity is normal, every game has this" no they don't, go to any other forums like eso or warframe and you see a much happier playerbase, its because your game is really bad right now dude!
Okay, point by point:
As always BoP materials are NOT an answer, if they are struggling to see that after all those years, then there is no hope. There is like million different approaches to make professions interesting, challenging and able to create decent gear. People are buying carries for the same amount of gold they would otherwise spend for raid ilvl crafted BoE. So basically they got BoP gear or/and mats for gold, which means that keeping BoP mats is pointless and any arguments against that are invalid.Example: You could reintroduce thistle tea like recipe. (1) Players need to obtain a recipe from old content place, possibly with some interesting quest or challenge. (2) Potion gives temporary buff/resto to certain class/classes. (3) It would be useful for casual/twink/raider/pvp but it wouldn't be absolutely necessary. (4) It could use old world mats so they wouldn't be useless anymore.Example 2: You could even make game more interesting with some simple stupid changes like adding a possibility to some chest in loch modan to drop some endgame gems.Just make the world worth exploring. Make the copper veins worth mining etc. I am tired of ghost iron, sky golems, %^&*load of people on single herb route in tiragarde, azerite rng, boring islands, removal of one of the best battlegrounds while keeping pointless isle of conquest, thousands of worthless currencies (I got mote of darkness and I don't even remember what is that for), BoP everywhere, not giving Alliance Vulpera race :)...
Someone mentioned that people play on faction dominated servers and so there are plenty of alliance dominated pvp servers where alliance ganged up on horde. Well except for the fact that the #1 alliance pvp server NA shares a shard with pretty much all horde dominated servers so even if your server was alliance dominated you were still overall dominated by horde.
A Mage Tower type solo challenge should be a part of every expansion in the future.