All those comments about the MDI just proved they've never actually watched the MDI in their life. They're just like bots.Any dungeon that had an RNG aspect (for example the maze in Mists, in SL) can be made consistent on the TOURNAMENT REALMS for the MDI if they decide it's best for the tournament. They don't to need change anything on live for the MDI.People who played retail when it was current didn't like the rotation because it requires learning multiple strats and some weeks because harder than others. And if that week had the worst affix on top of it, it could be brutal.
It's so weird to see people complain about consistency when rng mechanics and start changes have always been a pain in people's sides.
Gotta love seein the same people that QQ about random loot and other rng elements then complain they made freehold consistant.
I don't care about the MDI.I still like my dungeons being consistent. Randomness is a pain in the butt and is not gratifying.
Yes lets have the worst boss between the three to be always up. Genius decision making.
The only change they need to make for M+ is remove affix
Consistency in timed weekly content is never a bad thing, in my opinion.They made the right decision - this will benefit people trying to progress to 20 and higher just as much as those players who only play a few dungeons each week. Memorizing different routes or strategies in the same dungeon and learning from mistakes is much harder when there's 3 different versions of it.
I am really leaning towards the side of people claiming this is a good change. I would have liked for Eudora to be the ally, but we can manage far better getting used to the same captains every week, compared to doing three different routes with one route losing literally minutes compared to another one, just because this week had a different crew event. The fact that one third of the time you wanted to either have a stealth class with you or had to sacrifice players multiple times to not fight some trash packs should be enough for everybody recognize this dungeon never was balanced in the past just due to design. But I guess the people that want to keep the weekly crew rotation also like the boat ride in Court of Stars.
People acting like they want 1 week of 20 to be the easiest to get score in the dungeon. Its still there on normal, make a new char and do some bfa lore dungeoneering if you reaaaaally want it. Not really fun to have to have a class that can skip the dog event for example. This was not one of the reasons people liked freehold in m+ specifically.
Consistency is going to be great here, no more rotating weeks of captains. No need to wait for a certain week that might only show up once to push at, you'll have 3x the chances to do this.
Everyone when Karazhan Lower's first encounter has a random boss rotation: I sleepEveryone when Court of Stars has both the random interactive items as well as random spy disguises: I still sleepEveryone when Freehold now has a fixed boss encounter: ENRAGED!...seriously. This is a good change. Stop treating like it's not.