Can confirm the pigskin/football thing, you get two separate footballs or pigskins in toybox, so yes, name is same, itemID is not and ONLY the present counts for the FOS.
Those textures do not seem to be live. I have the green one with bell sleeves and pirate boots. Not cute.
Perc, you guys need to clarify to others before they get all confused in the site:They're Both Footballs? is Still Obtainable but you have to drop the Older ones, Special Edition Foot Ball and The Pigskin off the Stolen Present from the Event's daily (to kill Greench and free Metzen) not the Toy vendor (note the difference in their tooltips' source).Both items you have linked (Foot Ball and The Swineskin) are from the Toy vendor Jepetto in Dalaran, which have Different IDs (check their tooltips) and won't give credit to the FoS.